Lead-free soldering looks like a simple alloy swap until the first cold joint hits the test bench. SAC305 melts 34°C hotter than the tin-lead eutectic it replaced, so the reflow profile that worked for years now leaves dull, weak, or half-wet joints. AISMT supplies the temperature curve analyzers you need to see what the oven is actually doing. Here is what lead-free soldering demands of your alloy and your reflow profile, and where the process window shrinks.
SAC305 Melting Point and Why It Matters
The most common lead-free alloy is SAC305 — 96.5% tin, 3.0% silver, 0.5% copper — with a melting point of 217°C. That is 34°C above the 183°C eutectic of Sn63/Pb37 tin-lead solder, and that gap is the whole story. A higher melting point forces the reflow peak up, narrows the margin before parts are damaged, and gives flux less time to do its job.
The trade-off is real. SAC305 wets more poorly than tin-lead because its higher surface tension spreads less easily, which makes it more prone to open and cold joints. The fix is not a different alloy but tighter control of the profile that melts it.
The Lead-Free Reflow Temperature Profile
Lead-free soldering tolerates far less drift than tin-lead. A workable SAC305 reflow profile settings window looks like this:
| Stage | Range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Preheat | 150–170°C, 60–90 s | Ramp 1–3°C/s; activates flux, avoids thermal shock |
| Soak | 150–200°C, 60–120 s | Evens out board temperature, removes oxides |
| Reflow peak | 235–250°C | 20–30°C above liquidus; 30–90 s above 217°C |
| Cooling | 1–4°C/s down | Faster cooling gives finer grain and stronger joints |
Keep the ramp rate under control at the start. A preheat that climbs too fast — above 1.5°C/s on the preheat leg — boils off solvent before the flux activates, and you get solder spatter and voids. A soak that is too short leaves the board uneven, and large copper planes pull heat so the center lands 8–10°C cooler than the edge.
Intermetallic Compound and Why It Bites Twice
At the joint interface, tin reacts with the copper pad to form an intermetallic compound (IMC) — Cu₆Sn₅ first, then Cu₃Sn beneath it. A thin IMC layer is what makes the joint bond; it is also brittle, so its thickness must stay controlled.
Lead-free soldering grows IMC faster than tin-lead because of the higher temperature and the extra silver. Keep the time above liquidus between 30 and 90 seconds, and cool at 2–4°C/s. A slow, hot profile lets the IMC grow past 10 µm, at which point the joint turns brittle and the thermal fatigue life drops. Peak below 235°C and the alloy never fully wets; peak above 260°C and you scorch the package and the board.
Avoiding Cold Joints and Head-in-Pillow
Two lead-free-only defects deserve a name. A cold joint forms when the paste never fully melts, leaving a grainy, dull surface. Head-in-pillow hits BGA packages when the ball and the paste melt at different moments, so the ball sits on the paste without bonding.
Both trace back to heat delivery. Make sure the BGA balls and the paste cross the liquidus together by evening the soak, and consider nitrogen reflow — oxygen at or below 500 ppm — to cut oxidation and improve wetting. On a lead-free line, the profile is not set once; it is verified per board with a reflow oven profile and rechecked when the mix changes.
Hold the Profile, Not Just the Alloy
Lead-free soldering is a process, not a material. Swap the alloy and the work moves to the profile: preheat, soak, peak, and cooling all tighten around SAC305’s 217°C liquidus. Measure it with a profiler, control the atmosphere, and the cold joints and head-in-pillow defects stop appearing. AISMT keeps the SMT spare parts and profiling tools to keep a lead-free line inside that window.


Add comment